Mobile-Bearing Versus Fixed-Bearing Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty in Older Adults: A Critical Narrative Review of Outcomes, Failure Mechanisms and Age-Specific Decision-Making
Agus Eka Wiradiputra
Department of Orthopaedic and Traumatology, Bhayangkara Denpasar Hospital, Bali, Indonesia.
Made Bagus Bharata Wijaya *
Department of Orthopaedic and Traumatology, Bhayangkara Denpasar Hospital, Hayam Wuruk Street No112, Denpasar, Bali, 80239, Indonesia.
Febyan Febyan
Department of Orthopaedic and Traumatology, Bhayangkara Denpasar Hospital, Faculty of Medicine Udayana University, Bali, Indonesia.
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Abstract
Unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) can relieve pain and preserve native knee structures in carefully selected patients with isolated compartmental osteoarthritis. Whether a mobile-bearing or fixed-bearing articulation is preferable in older adults remains unsettled. Age-related changes in bone quality, activity, comorbidity and competing mortality may alter the importance of implant-specific hazards, yet much comparative research pools patients of different ages and confounds bearing mobility with implant systems and operative practice. This critical narrative review integrates direct comparative studies, randomised evidence, registry analyses, biomechanical investigations and older-patient cohorts published through 7 September 2026. The synthesis differentiates medial from lateral UKA, short-term symptom recovery from long-term revision risk, and implant survival from patient survival. Small non-randomised comparisons confined to octogenarians and adults aged at least 75 years report favourable outcomes with both designs and no detected average functional advantage; limited events, ceiling effects and implant-system confounding restrict inference. A broader, younger-skewed multicentre cohort reported some early advantages for mobile-bearing implants but greater cost and dislocation, while a ten-year randomised comparison found comparable patient-reported function and more revisions with mobile bearings. Meta-analyses are sensitive to observational versus randomised designs and cannot establish a universal superior articulation. Mobile-bearing dislocation and fixed-bearing polyethylene, fixation or fracture problems are distinct, technique-sensitive risks rather than inevitable design outcomes. Revision probabilities in advanced age additionally depend on exposure time, surgeon experience, compartment, underlying anatomy and death as a competing event. The defensible conclusion is that chronological age alone neither contraindicates UKA nor determines bearing selection. For older adults, choice should integrate compartment-specific biomechanics, patient priorities, bone and ligament status, surgeon proficiency, implant-specific evidence and expected years at risk. Prospective age-stratified comparisons using standardised complications, competing-risk analyses and patient-centred outcomes remain necessary.
Keywords: Medial compartment osteoarthritis, lateral compartment osteoarthritis, implant survivorship, bearing dislocation, octogenarians, patient-reported outcomes, competing risks, arthroplasty revision